| |
Introduction
Our age seems to be very rich in
sexual matters: rape, heinous sex crimes,
adultery, skyrocketing divorce rates,
prostitution, paedophilia, abortion,
pornography in its manifold forms and
materials: blue movies, internet sex,
pornographic compact disks, etc. Without sex
T.V. programs are less attractive. Sex even
powerfully affects the very stock exchange
dax index in today’s business world! The
clever businesspeople know how to conduct a
successful business, how to sell their
products in the easiest and most profitable
way through sex. Sexual appeal has become a
business strategy, the sure means to maximum
profit: sex appeal in fashion and in
clothes, in advertisements, in internet
shopping, in the media. Society adopts it
unconsciously and lives with it as
individuals, as groups and as organisations.
Then it is said: “Sex is in!”
This article is an attempt to recall
and to highlight some African and Christian
principles of sexual morality in the fight
against HIV/AIDS. It must be clearly stated
that it should not be assumed that there is
a great moral vacuum in the traditional
understanding of sexuality in Africa
compared to Christian morality: on the
contrary, there is a rich, sound moral
inheritance. But, like almost everywhere
else in the world, there is also much moral
confusion in the African continent since
the Sexual Revolution of 1960s. So the task
of the moment may be to remind people of
their faded memories of their valuable and
relevant sexual moral principles and
reinforce them with universal Christian
moral principles. This may achieve greater
emphasis in the African context as
Christianity gains increasing relevance in
the continent. The task to face and
eradicate the fatal AIDS pandemic does not
come from a mandate outside Christianity,
but by its very nature, from its founder,
Jesus Christ. The task in the African
continent may be to compliment and reinforce
traditional sexual moral principles in an
appropriate way with universal Christian
moral principles as a solution in the fight
against HIV/AIDS.[1]
Arrival of Contraceptives and its Negative
Effects
Sociologists date the beginning of
the serious moral confusion that relates
closely to the AIDS pandemic from the
arrival of new contraceptives that enable
women to regulate or even avoid pregnancy.
Contraceptives have caused serious changes
in the understanding of sexual morality and
in the sexual behaviour of people throughout
the world. On one hand contraceptives help
both the partners avoid any kind of after
effects, particularly, pregnancy. On other
hand it liberalises them to engage in sexual
activities with any sexual partners without
marriage or without any kind of life-long
obligations to one another. So the pill
ensures and increases the possibility of
sexual activity without any risk! The
effectiveness of new contraceptive methods
also enables sex to be regarded as an act
“just for fun” without considering its
procreative role. According to this maxim
more sexual activities means more fun. As a
consequence self-control is reduced in the
urge for sexual gratification. At the same
time it diminishes the original
understanding of sexuality as a deep,
intensive and exclusive expression of the
partnership relationship between a man and a
woman. These new methods could seriously
take away the important entities of
sexuality, that is the expression of the
exclusive love between a man and a woman and
its purpose for procreation in the context
of a married life.
If the whole of sexual orientation
is directed solely towards self-satisfaction
the understanding of an intimate sexual
relationship between two autonomous persons,
not bound to one another and free to
dissolve their relationship at any time, as
temporary, endangers the sociological aspect
of the ‘we’ of husband and wife and
their life-long and inseparable partnership
in love. Sexual activity then becomes like a
customary sex-business relationship. Human
sexuality becomes an exchangeable good in
the play between a man and a woman! In other
words a laissez-faire affair destabilises
the protective character of the relationship
between a man and a woman. Sexuality, which
once contributed to the stability of a
relationship and partnership between a man
and a woman, is changed into a factor of
instability between both of them. The
traditional concept of sexuality as a
powerful, exclusive, intimate, physical and
psychological expression of love is now
degraded into an object! In certain cases a
partner is selected on the basis of the
sexiness of their appearance. The authentic
human relationship between a man and a
woman, which is to be steered by the
principles of real love, dedication,
sacrifice, trust, and renunciation for one
another for the sake of the stability of the
partnership is then replaced by mere feeling
for one another. And when there is no
feeling left, then there would not be a deep
relationship! The dignity of the person is
increasingly and unconsciously degraded!
In short: the use of technical-pharmaceutical
contraceptives causes a destabilisation and
breakdown of relationships. It makes it
possible to deprive a partnership of
exclusiveness and, at the same time, allows
the possibility of pre-marital and
extra-marital sexual relationships without
any contraceptive risks.[2]
On the other hand sexual relationships
between unmarried persons are often seen as
test acts. Common jargon proves this new way
of thinking. “Love without sex is like chai
(= tea) without sugar!” “You cannot buy a
commodity without first unwrapping it!” “You
cannot buy groundnuts without first tasting
them!” Or regarding extra-marital sex they
say: “A fool thinks that his wife's dishes
are the most delicious and you will not know
that your wife's dishes are not the best
until you taste others outside!” And even if
you seriously warn them of the dreadful
danger of HIV/AIDS they laugh at you and
argue about the reliability of the latex or
rubber solution of condoms! “A cow chews
grass and cuds till it dies with them in its
mouth!”
Since contraception blocks the
beginning of a new life, of an offspring,
the sexual union between man and woman is
without its procreative goal, which is
important in African sexual morality. A new
born baby is fully dependent on its parents,
mother and father, from the very beginning
for its physiological, psychological and
sociological needs. In its turn it binds its
father and mother together more closely and
silently reminds them both that they have to
live together and work for the sake of the
child. The absence of an offspring leaves a
goal vacuum and does not help create a
strong bond between a man and a woman.
Further, the propagation and
implementation of contraceptives as safe sex
methods destabilises traditional and healthy
sexual moral principles since they can be
used with any one, and not necessarily only
in a married partnership. It is also to be
noted that in the fight against AIDS by
means of safe sex condoms are propagated as
a means to “protect yourself”. But
practically nothing is heard about the
increased possibility and practice of
promiscuity, which is one of the most
serious reasons for the spread of HIV/AIDS.
Though the government and
non-governmental agencies propagate an
AIDS-free-country or continent, their
actions suggest they are resigned to the
dying moral principles of society. Often the
preventive message works as a contradictory
message: “Use condoms and do what you want
to do!”[3]
Could the silence as regards moral
principles be because of the current moral
confusion? There is scarcely any interest in
discussing the issue of AIDS from the
ethical point of view though it touches
almost all dimensions of human behaviour. It
is treated as a taboo theme. But as long as
all the energy is concentrated solely on the
fight against the ways of infection and not
with the real causes of a fatal behaviour
how do we eradicate the fatal pandemic! We
are caught up in a vicious circle. In spite
of intensified advertisements against
HIV/AIDS, the pandemic is increasing rapidly
and compels us to rethink our strategies.[4]
The prevailing deep silence with
regard to sexual principles in society
seriously affects the younger generation.
Whereas in former times parents or elderly
persons gave sexual moral education to the
younger generation, and certain cultural
practices supported the teachings on how to
retain moral integrity, today there is an
increasing silence. At the same time it must
also be said that what has crept into the
world of adults is now also accessible to
the younger generation without much censure.
To a great extent they copy the promiscuous
behaviour of their elders and believe that
the whole purpose of sexuality is only for
genital satisfaction and pleasure. According
to UNAIDS studies the age at which the young
generation have their first sexual
experience is becoming considerably and
astonishingly lower than in former times.[5]
Whereas parents and other responsible
persons in a society encourage the younger
generation to live more and more efficient,
productive, rich lives with excellent
academic qualifications, education for a
morally good life is more and more
neglected. Often the media or their peers
act as their educators, which damages their
moral integrity rather than builds it up.
When we summarise the impact of new technical-pharmaceutical
contraception since its arrival to help
prevent unwanted after-effects of sexual
activity, we notice that there is a
considerable change in sexual behaviour:
increased sexual contacts, increased number
of sexual partners, an ease in which people
live and experience intimate sexuality
without any obligations to their partner,
dropping out of the marriage bond and the
life long promise to be faithful to the
another partner, etc.
Propitious Ground for the Spread of HIV/AIDS
When these few observations are
considered one can agree with the social
findings M. D. Grmek that account for the
high prevalence of HIV/AIDS: “Liberated from
the yoke of behavioural expectations imposed
by traditions of small village groups, the
inhabitants of the big cities abandoned
themselves heartily to elaborate sexual
play. Urban prostitution, and still more the
emergence of new categories of ‘free women’
and single men, promoted a multiplicity of
partners. In such a new social situation the
HIV virus found a propitious setting for its
propagation.”[6]
The deviation from sound moral
principles also causes the increasing number
of abortions in the continent due to
unwanted pregnancies.[7]
In short: the sexual gift endowed by God
from the very beginning of humanity has
become our main insoluble problem in the age
of AIDS. As long as HIV/AIDS remains
primarily a behavioural disease, there is no
escaping the task of restoring morally
correct behaviour along with the
possibilities of medical treatment. Put
simply: the war against AIDS will not be won
solely by implementing the use of condoms.[8]
It is clear that moral appeals and warnings
about the fatal nature of the virus have not
penetrated deeply into the hearts of people
since there is no noticeable decrease in the
infection of the virus and death rates due
to HIV/AIDS, but rather an increase in
infections in many countries. “You don’t get
AIDS, but you acquire AIDS”[9]
which is true in about 90% of cases. This
deficiency is acquired mostly by
wrong sexual behaviour. So the task of the
hour is to help people change their
behaviour so that they can lead a sound and
healthy life.
Though the churches exercise the role of the Good
Samaritan to nurse the crestfallen humans,
the task of defeating and healing the fatal
structures with regard to AIDS remains for
her! This can not be limited to occasional
moral appeals! The process of
conscientization is the challenge of today.
This is much harder than moral appeals like:
“Keep abstinence!” “Don’t use condoms” “Be
faithful to your partner!”…. “AIDS
prevention – to be worthy of the human
person and at the same time truly effective
– must propose two objectives: to inform
adequately and to educate for
responsibility,”[10]
says Pope John Paul II. In other words it is
the task of education that each and every
person in the continent understands that the
gift of human sexuality given by God is to
be lived in its full meaning with deep sense
of responsibility: for the expression of
love between married partners and for the
pro-creative and co-creative goal. And the
role of the sexual ethics is precisely this:
to help the people to achieve this goal.
When we critically analyse the history of
ethics we see the fact that ethical
principles are becoming more and more
relevant and significant when all other
solutions, such as technical-artificial
ones, prove themselves less useful.
Diversity in Search of a Solution
It is
necessary to do everything possible to save
human lives which are attacked in a fatal
way and decimate humanity in the most
pathetic way. Everything possible should be
done both to stop the further spread of
infection and to cure the infected. With the
rapid spread of the fatal infection, the
appropriate scientific-technical solutions
to stop the pandemic are to find
vaccinations for the prevention of the HIV
infection, and medical treatments for those
already infected through drugs such as
anti-retroviral treatments. At the same time
questions must also to be asked about the
scientific-technical solutions: do these
solutions, wrongly understood, bring new
unsolvable problems for humanity? Will the
present moral problems be over-obscured by
the new solutions? Are the new
medical-technical solutions a further
blank-cheque for sexual behaviour which
would create a new chain of problems? Peter
Piot, Executive Director of Joint United
Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS warned
seriously in his concluding words to the
ICASA in Nairobi (International Conference
on AIDS and STIs in Africa) on 26th
September 2003:“I want to emphasise that
Africa should not make the same mistake as
the West did when ARVs became available. And
that mistake was dropping the ball on
prevention, based on the naïve belief that
treatment would be enough to stop the
epidemic…. The result was terrifying: an
increase in infection! So, while we do
everything we can to increase access to HIV
treatment, we should equally scale up
prevention efforts.”[11]
Although the availability of new medical
facilities have prolonged infected lives in
the world of AIDS, the beginning of an
eradication is not yet in sight. What could
help us in this precarious situation?
A very powerful advertisement to
fight against the AIDS is: “Stop AIDS. It
begins with you!” But in spite of this
direct command it is observed that it
remains as an appeal! Though all possible
means are undertaken such as through mass
media, T.V., Radio, News paper, Posters,
leaflets, the rate of infection goes up and
up. The reasons are apparent first in human
thinking patterns of humans, and then also
in social and environmental customs and
practices.
1.
Personal Aspects of Sexuality
People do not like any outside
interference in matters of sexuality. They
claim that sexuality is the exclusive
concern of each individual. It is said:
“neither the government, nor the churches,
nor the NGOs must interfere in people’s
private lives. The way in which sexuality is
exercised is the exclusive concern of each
individual person.” At the same time
government, churches, NGOs, etc. are forced
to take actions to alleviate the suffering
that is due to this privatised sexual
morality and morally wrong activity in order
to save lives. Moreover, nobody can deny the
intrinsic relationship that exists between
human sexuality and marriage, and that any
prudent society should uphold the moral
principles. Therefore, though people have a
certain exclusive right about whether to
accept moral values, the duty of moral
reawakening by higher authorities is
unavoidable. This social dimension of
education has greater emphasis in the
African context since sexuality is also
understood in its social dimension.
2.
Responsibility
AIDS forces each and every
individual to exercise sexuality with
extreme responsibility. But very often
people are not educated as to why they have
to take responsibility, why sexual
activities should be limited only to the
legal partner whom they marry, and why
marriage is the exclusive place for the
sexual activities of husband and wife etc.
And this moral confusion demands
ethical-educational steps to sharpen the
conscience of a person.
3.
Well-formed Conscience
As HIV/AIDS is a health issue the
infected persons are necessarily in
consultation with medical professionals who
have a serious obligation to inform their
patients in detail about the status of their
infection and also to inform them about all
the possible modes of transmitting this
fatal infection to others through his/her
morally disordered behaviour. Only a
well-formed conscience could enable an
infected person to behave responsibly so
that no further infection to other persons
occurs. It is a question of ethics based on
the Principle of a Well-Formed Conscience.
To form true, responsible actions, in every
free decision involving an ethical question,
persons are morally obliged to do the
following: to be informed as fully as
practically possible about the facts of
infection and its related ethical norms.
Further, they have to form a morally certain
judgment of conscience on the basis of this
information. And their actions, especially
the sexual activities should be then out of
this well-formed conscience and they have to
take the responsibility for their actions.
On other hand medical ethics sternly
prohibits any kind of exchange of medical
information to anyone other than the patient
him/herself (Principle of Confidentiality).
So they find themselves in a precarious
situation. But medical professionals are the
first and important people who are able
support the infected person and help them
during this time of fear to effect a
behavioural change so that no more people
are endangered by the infected person’s
actions. Of course this has to be done with
much sensitivity and skill. They could, with
the clear consent of the infected person, be
a bridge to reveal the status of infection
to the sexual partner. But it is doubtful
whether they take this obligation seriously.
So such silence around the infected status
of a person without proper preventive
methods means the sure spread of further
infection to the his/her sexual partner.
4.
Empowerment for a Personal Decision for a
Morally Good Life
Sr. Kay Lawlor, a Medical Missionary
of Mary, tells the story of how in 1988,
while at a high school celebration in
Uganda, she suggested an AIDS seminar for
the new students. The headmistress surprised
her, saying “I can’t listen to another talk
on AIDS. You come here and tell us how it’s
transmitted and how fast it‘s spreading and
each time the statistics get worse. No one
is helping us to stop it.” This shocked Sr.
Kay. Defensively she said: “It’s not
possible to stop it if the people themselves
won’t change their behaviour”. “Help them to
do it then”, the headmistress retorted. Sr.
Kay left with that statement ringing in her
ears. The seed had been sown. “Behaviour
Change: The Education for Life Process”
resulted. And it is to be acknowledged that
this program has substantially contributed
to a staggering reduction in the prevalence
of AIDS in Uganda, from 28.9% at the height
of the Epidemic to 9.8%, according to the UN
figures. Young people were challenged to
change their morally wrong behaviour by
means of education, moral instructions, and
above by means of strengthening them for
self control.[12]
Responsible behaviour means more
than not violating any rights of others and
not endangering others’ life. Ethical
principles cannot be fulfilled by negative
concepts or moral prohibitions alone. A
lifestyle full of prohibitions and negative
instructions will be not be accepted as the
experience of Sr. Kay of Uganda shows. Nor
can it be limited only to the maxim: “Be
kind to others” and to their morally
disordered lifestyle. It has to be derived
from positive fundamental principles and the
decisions of all persons concerned.
Since the primary responsibility for
a person’s health rests on the individual
him/herself, people must be empowered.
According to Christian understanding every
person has a responsibility to choose the
optimal ways for a healthy life since life
itself originates from God. Even the Father
of Medicine, Hipocrates, prescribes an order
in medicine: first the regimen, the
person’s lifestyle, then the medicinal
treatment.[13]
Therefore the first aim in the fight against
AIDS is education for a healthy lifestyle,
not only for body, but also for the soul. In
the stream of the pluralistic lifestyles of
our age one has to critically select and
decide on the correct one which guarantees a
healthy life of oneself as well as that of
others.
5. Suppport by Society
Though the individual person is
responsible for his/her conduct, society too
has an obligation to support the individual
choice of a responsible lifestyle. With AIDS
we experience that the negative effects of
personal choice affects society itself as
well as other members of the society. So any
silence over moral values on the part of
society could ruin society itself.
“Permissivism means a regression of values;
it destroys one of the instruments necessary
in the fight against AIDS.”[14]
The society has to find new ways how to
support its members through forms of
culture, and revive supporting traditional
practices for healthy ways of living.
Some Reflections on Sexuality with Regard to
AIDS
The understanding of human sexuality
in its relation to HIV/AIDS still remains
the challenge. It means understanding the
person in his/her anthropological fullness.
Sexuality, according to the understanding of
one prominent natural scientist, medical
doctor and theologian of the Middle Ages,
St. Hildegard of Bingen (1098-1179)[15]
belongs to the fundamental constitution of a
human, (constitutio prima), which is
designed by God. The creation of a human are
as sexus is reflected in each and
every part of the human body as well as the
soul. And in sexual life find the humans the
fullness of the embodiment of a person.[16]
So it is impossible to have any ethical
discussion on AIDS without discussing how a
particular group of people understand
sexuality. With regard to the ethical
discussion on HIV/AIDS, Laurenti Magesa
- a veteran in the
East African Ethics as well as a competent
dialogue partner with the West
- complains that
“there is evident lack of cultural
sensitivity in the discussion of AIDS and
Africa, both in the social-medical and
religious spheres.”[17]
So there can be no substantial solution in
the fight against HIV/AIDS without taking a
serious understanding of sexuality in the
African culture into consideration.
Some Important African Understandings about
Sexuality
Against the double dimensions of
sexuality in Christianity it is to be noted
that there is a triple dimension of
sexuality in the African understanding
according to John S. Mbiti: procreative,
religious and social. At a time when
sexuality is understood and practised more
and more as a means for pure personal
pleasure, in African culture it is a sacred
phenomenon. Sexual activity is understood
“as a sacred action, as a sacrament,
signifying inward spiritual values”.
Therefore any jokes about genital organs or
a look at them, especially those of parents
are severe trespasses against the sacredness
of sexuality. Further, “sexual organs are
gates of life”. Thy are meant primarily for
the promotion of life. Since life is the
most precious value of all, adultery is seen
as a serious offence against the community
laws and orders. “In some societies the
guilty person (particularly a man) would be
whipped, stoned to death, made to pay
compensation or have his head or other part
of his body mutilated. … Fornication,
incest, rape, seduction, homosexual
relations, sleeping with a forbidden
‘relative’ or domestic animals, intimacy
between relatives, children watching the
genitals of their parents (in the wide usage
of the term), all constitute sexual offences
in a given community. Society deals
variously with these offences, and African
people are very sensitive to any departure
from the accepted norm concerning all
aspects of sex. This is a fundamentally
religious attitude, since any offence upsets
the smooth relationships of the community
which includes those who have already
departed.”[18]
Virginity
In many tribal traditions virginity
is highly esteemed and valued. There are
even certain rituals in the family and among
the relatives to signify the value of
virginity. “The blood of virginity is the
symbol that life has been preserved, that
the spring of life has not already been
flowing wastefully, and that both the girl
and her relatives have preserved the
sanctity of human reproduction. Only
marriage may shed this sacred blood….
Virginity symbolizes purity not only of the
body but also of moral life, and a virgin
bride is the greatest glory and crown to her
parents, husband and relatives.”[19]
Sacredness of Sexuality and Married life
The seriousness of sexual offences
is very great. In case any offences against
sexual morals have occurred there are
certain prescriptions for ritual cleansing
in the belief that such offences would cause
misfortunes. Through these kinds of
procedures the religious dimension of
sexuality is strongly emphasised. The
marriage, the wedding ceremony it self, the
lobola (bridal wealth) are understood
as expressions of religious happenings,
saying, “We are making a sacred
undertaking!” and all expressions of
sexuality have a religious dimensions in
married life and social life. So in respect
of this religious and social dimension Mbiti
says: “Marriage is, therefore, a sacred
drama in which everybody is a religious
participant, and no normal person may keep
away from this dynamic scene of action”.[20]
Further, the revitalisation with the
departed, the living and the yet to be born
is stressed as the historical dimension of a
marriage so that the newly married are
integrated into the totality of the family
and clan.
Social Aspect of Married Life
The social aspect of marriage in
African understanding is the full unity of
the wife with the husband and his family.
According to some African customs (e.g.
Batoro) the bride is be carried on the
shoulders on her way to the husband’s house.
This dramatized act is an expression of the
new stage in the married woman’s life, that
she is now being cut off from her own family
and will be joined to the new family of the
husband. She is then fully integrated in the
clan, tribe and society of the husband. What
better lively expression could be given to
the words of Jesus where a separation from
the parents through marriage has to take
place (cf. Mt 19:4; Mk 10:7; Gn 2:24)![21]
Procreative Aspect of Married Life
Married life without a procreative
dimension is unthinkable in the
understanding of African marriage and it is
stressed and accepted as an inseparable
dimension of it. So it fulfils one of the
Christian dimensions of marriage in its full
sense. Negligence in the contribution of
life through procreation is understood as
loss of original immortality of the persons,
which was given by God and breaks the chain
of humanity.
AIDS and African Cosmology
In spite of some of this very rich
understanding of sexuality the people of
Africa are now confronted directly with the
reality of AIDS. In search of ethical
solutions one has, as far as possible, to
take the African paradigm itself seriously
into consideration. A very deep and correct
perception of their world, culture,
language, traditions, etc. is needed for any
kind of ethical solution. Further, any
solutions imported from outside the culture
and understanding would not help to rebuild
the moral integrity of the African people.
So Magesa suggests that the cosmology of an
African People must first be understood. It
is the understanding of their own particular
world which shapes their actions in respect
of themselves and each other, and informs
how they interpret the consequences of their
actions. “This dialectic of
cause-effect-cause between cosmological
perception and human behaviour forms the
context in which ultimate reality is
interpreted.”[22]
With regard to HIV/AIDS Magesa sees three
important existent cosmologies in African
understanding.
Cosmological Perspective of Tradition
The first one is the Traditional
Cosmological Perspective, which influences
the sexual behaviour and moral outlook of
the people concerned in a different way.
According to traditional understanding the
violation of values of honesty and justice
(even in business transactions) is a serious
crime.[23]
It may seem absurd that a violation in trade
could causes AIDS. But the moral message of
the whole issue must be appreciated. In
other words, a serious violation of moral
principles is even assumed to cause an
incurable illness, even to endanger life
itself! This cosmology refers to “the aspect
of the consciousness of human community and
interpersonal bonding; that harm done to one
person or group of persons tends to spread.
Sometimes it boomerangs on its perpetrator.
This awareness, so strong in the traditional
African world-view, is indispensable in
inspiring responsible sexual morality and
helping in the control of AIDS in Africa.”[24]
Cosmological Perspective of Sexual Morals
The second cosmological perspective
deals with sexual morals. Even though people
know that AIDS is a disease acquired through
sexual promiscuity and not from the world of
magic and through the power of witchcraft,
there is a certain confusion and certain
perplexity regarding sexual behaviour. The
span between their knowledge and their
behavioural change still seems to be
unbridgeable! In other words, people need
more help to see why they have to change
their behaviour and how they could change
their behaviour.
Cosmological Perspective of Promiscuity
According to the third cosmological
perspective Magesa sees a direct link
between AIDS and Sexual Promiscuity. Though
there is much denial about promiscuity the
rising number of HIV infection and deaths
due to AIDS is to be taken seriously under
the reality of the third cosmological
perspective. “In many parts of Africa, the
link between sexual behaviour and AIDS is
now well-established in the minds of the
majority. A change in sexual behaviour does
not follow suit, however”.[25]
The current Challenge to the African and
Christian understanding of Sexuality
Having seen in brief some reasons for the shift in
moral principles on the one hand, and
valuable African moral principles on other,
the challenge is now how to integrate the
valuable and still relevant ethical values
in the fight against HIV/AIDS. The African
continent, which is becoming more and more
Christian, possesses a great tradition of
sexual morality. The present challenge is to
complement African moral principles with
Christian moral principles. Therefore it
would be appropriate to see some
theological, anthropological understanding
of humans which are universal and capable of
complementing the African moral values.
Theological and Anthropological
Understanding of Human Sexuality
The inner meaning of human sexuality
is to be found in the fundamental
understanding of the human anthropology. It
is pictured in its basic and fundamental
form in Holy Scripture. The first humans,
Adam and Eve represent us all in a
figurative language in our sexual nature in
all its beauty and power. It is God’s
creation with his Spirit. It is with the
same Spirit of God that the Trinity exists
and how God the Father and the Son exist in
the love of the Holy Spirit that was
breathed into the first human, Adam. Though
the term sexuality as such is not directly
found in Scripture, we find its description
in its language. The expressions are
sometimes indirect
- also due to its
mysterious nature
- and sometimes
direct, like the nakedness of the man and
woman (cf. Gn 2:25), the feelings of shame
(cf. Gn 3:7; 10), or the need to protect the
nakedness (cf. Gn 3:7; 21), or regarding
pregnancy (cf. Gn 3:16). Further, the
thinking pattern of sexuality, its exercise
and the offspring, the sons and earthly
daughters, are stated in connection with the
heavenly sons to express how beautiful and
wonderful the offspring out of sexuality
could be! In short human sexuality is seen
as a gift of God for humans whereas the
deviation from the nature and aims of
sexuality are seen as immoral, e.g. incest,
homosexuality, and sodomy, etc.
According to the Jahvist creation
narrative the partnership in the institution
of marriage and family is God’s intention:
“It is not good for man to be alone. I will
make a suitable partner for him” (Gn 2:18).
The human, who has supremacy over all the
creation, is given help for his fulfilment
and wholeness in the woman who is “… is bone
of my bones and flesh of my flesh” (Gn
2:23). Therefore these two have to live in
such an intimacy and interdependence that “a
man leaves his father and mother and clings
to his wife, and the two of them become one
body” (Gn 2:24).[26]
Two important messages are given here: their
equality and their different sexuality (Gn
1:27; 2:18-25). Further, man and woman are
joined together for pro-creation (Gn 1:28;
2:24; 3:16; 4:1 ff.) which is often
described in allegorical expressions such as
“knowing one another” “to come to the wife”,
“to see the nakedness”, “to take the wife”,
“to lay near the other”, “to sleep together”
etc. This is the fundamental reason why
sexuality is to be exercised between these
two only
- since both of
them live with one another only, and since
both are united in the spirit, psyche, mind,
and heart in such a way that even their
bodies experience their intimacy as one body
in the sexual acts.
Sexuality in the New Testament
In the New Testament we see the very clear prohibitions
regarding extra marital and non-natural
sexual activity. In his statement about
marriage Jesus says clearly and radically
that the foundation for the partnership
between a man and a woman is an exclusive
love between these two alone and that the
seriousness and depth of this relationship
is an act of God himself. “What God has
jointed together, no human being must
separate” (Mk 10:9). Any other form of
partnership is condemned by Jesus very
clearly as a deviation from morality, and as
adultery. A very restrictive sexual ethic is
drawn by Jesus himself. It aims at the
liberal sexual practices of men of
antiquity. Jesus’ strict prohibition on
divorce (Mk 10:9; 1 Cor 7:10) was against
the prevalent practices of the Jews and the
Pagans. And he establishes the seriousness
of this prohibition in the structure of
creation where the sexual order of man and
woman is stated. Jesus deepens the
prohibition against adultery saying that
even a lustful look at a woman is to be
avoided so that the institution of the
married person is protected by all means
(cf. Mt 5:27 ff). Further, we see in the
writings of Paul how strictly the integrity
of the married life and the equality of both
man and women were pursued. “The husband
should fulfil his duty towards his wife, and
likewise the wife towards her husband” (1
Cor 7:3a)
- a revolutionary
statement against the practices of antiquity
where the man had the power over sexual
activities with the woman and the women had
always to be submissive to him! In 1 Thes
4:4 ff we see how the sexual activities even
in the married life are ordered and to be
practiced with balance. We see also in these
statements how the faithful were advised in
the early church to keep married life holy
and to be keen to keep the order of the
creation in their lives. Dangers of misuse
are the first ones in the list of all the
vices: Heb 13:4; Gal 5:19; Col 3:5. They are
to be forbidden in order to avoid all forms
of immoral sexual activities. A special
verdict is given against homosexual activity
of men and women, which is seen as being
against Natural Law: Rom 1:26 f; 1. Cor 6:9;
1 Tm 1:10.
The Church and Sexual Moral Principles
The Church has not been silent about
the mystery of married life in any way up to
the present day. Even the Council of Trent
said that the real reason why husband and
wife are joined together sexually is because
of the fact of the mystery between both of
them. There is no deeper friendship than in
married life, in which husband and wife are
in the most intimate form of love and
concern for one another as the image of the
covenant of Christ with his Church. In this
love each person shows their partner
commitment and the deepest love for one
another.[27]
One of the greatest scholastic theologians
of Middle Ages, Alexander of Hales (*ca.
1185 in Hales and †21.08.1245 in Paris)
dares to say that the conjugal act of
married persons reflects the deepest love of
God to humanity; sexual love is the binding
power that unites them in lifelong
community. So the real understanding of
sexuality and its practices is interpreted
and taught by the Church from time
immemorial.[28]
Role of the Church Today
The church today exercises the role of the Good
Samaritan with deep dedication to nurse the
crestfallen suffering from HIV/AIDS. It is
very praiseworthy and is appreciated even by
Non-Christians and atheists. But a healing
is not yet possible in the case of
crestfallen humans under HIV/AIDS as in the
case of the wounded man of Jesus’ story of
Good Samaritan. The story of Jesus does not
say anything about the possibility of a
second attack on the same traveller or
another person under the same circumstance.
In that case the unanswered question
remains: What to do so that no more attacks
will happen and travellers are able to reach
their destinations of life safely without
fear and anxiety? The challenge of HIV/AIDS
is the same it seems. Till each and everyone
in the continent has completely defeat the
fatal structures of HIV/AIDS, the Church and
society will not have completed their
mission.
It is an effective programme to
provide people with a positive appreciation
of responsible sexuality based on the
principles of African and Biblical moral
values. It is the new method to combat the
immensely attractive power of the media
where the value of sexuality is made cheap.
It is above all the spiritual, liturgical,
psychological and educational supports that
really understand the people in their search
for permanent values. It is an
intensification of the support for AIDS
victims without any condemnation and
prejudice. It is the protection of the
dignity of human sexuality, which is
envisaged and given by God himself. It is
the challenge to understand sexuality in our
search for the meaning of life.
Conclusion
In this brief reflection we have
seen how the traditional, healthy, valuable
and bold sexual moral principles are shaken
or even swept away to certain extend in the
flow of the time and its influences. And as
long as HIV/AIDS is closely related to the
human sexuality it is a serious challenge to
a particular community, country and
continent to their sexual understanding and
its practices. So the challenge of to the
African and Christian understanding of
sexual moral principles has to derive new
forms of educational methods and
implementation of healthy sexual moral
principles which would substantially help to
eradicate the infectious behaviours of
humans; in other words, to help people
change their paths of unhealthy behaviour to
healthy, fully human and Christian life. And
it is nothing but the task and challenge of
an internal and dynamic exercise of
sexuality which enables the human love to be
fully meaningful as God designed it to be.
[1]
Laurenti Magesa observes on the basis of
studies by Sulayman S. Nyang and S.
Haneef that Islam has had more success
in keeping traditional moral values and
customs in Africa than Christianity.
S.S. Nyang: Islam, Christianity and
African Identity. (Bittelboro: Amana
Books) 1984 and of S. Haneef: What
Everyone should know about Islam and
Muslims. (Chicago: Kazi Publications)
1979. Cf. In: L. Magesa: “AIDS and
Survival in Africa: a tentative
reflection’. p 205-207. But this does
not necessarily mean that Christian
moral principles are practised with
laxity everywhere in Africa and that
they inadequate to bring clarity to the
present situation. Such a generalisation
does not reflect the sincere and
integral lives of many Christians in the
continent and could lead the people into
further mental and moral confusion.
[2]
The reasons for this kind of practice
may be manifold: dissatisfaction with
the sexual practices between the
partners, illness of one partner, love,
sentimental relationship with somebody,
sex as means for receiving privileges,
sexual adventures etc.
[3]
In
one of the film clips advertising the
use of condoms against the spread of
AIDS the contradictory message of the
film comes at the end, as the strange
young beautiful lady takes a condom from
her hand bag and puts it on the gun
barrel of the strange young man as he
enters a new town! The unsaid double
message given here could only be this:
“Enjoy your sexual pleasure with the
stranger using the condom!”
[4]
Some of the still prevalent sexual
customs and behaviour in Africa were not
of that fatal character before the
arrival of AIDS in the continent, such
as circumcision, wife inheritance,
hospitality through sexual
submissiveness, etc. But the arrival of
AIDS in the continent compels rethinking
about them and, if necessary, changing
and abolishing them. Customs are not
unchangeable and are subject to
purification.
[5]
UNAIDS: Knowledge and behavioural
indicators. In: Report on the global
HIV/AIDS epidemic 2002 (Geneva) 2002, p.
193. (The next report on the Global
epidemic will be published in July 2004
at the International Conference on AIDS
in Bangkok).
[6]
M. D. Grmek: History of AIDS:Emergence
and Origin of a Modern Epidemic.
-
(Princeton: Princeton University Press)
1990, p. 176.
[7]
“According to the report of a study on
the magnitude and consequences of unsafe
abortion, more than 300,000 abortions
occur in the country annually and the
Government spends Ksh 18.1 million on
post abortion care.…. The report states
that over 20,000 women and girls with
incomplete abortions are admitted
annually to public hospitals. And four
out of 10 women who die from unsafe
abortion complications are aged 20 to 34
years.” East African Standard, Friday,
May 7, 2004, p. 40.
[8]
George Nyabera: “AIDS war is not going
to be won by condoms”. In: East African
Standard, Sat. April 24, 2004. p. 8.
[9]
AIDS stands for the abbreviation of
Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome.
[10]
John Paul II: “The Church in Face of the
Twofold Challenge in AIDS.” In: To live:
Why? AIDS. – Proceedings of the Fourth
International Conference. Dolentium
Hominum No 13, 1990, p. 7.
[11]
Personal notes during the participation
in ICSA 21-26 September 2003.
[12]
This venture hit even the headlines of
“The Times Weekend” on Saturday, July
29, 2000. Cf. Catholic Medical
Quarterly. Journal of the Guild of
Catholic Doctors (London), Vol. L. No. 4
(290) Nov. 2000, p. 8-9.
[13]
Throughout the History of Medicine it is
seen how the importance of a correct
regimen for a healthy life is stressed
and understood as proper to the
Christian way of living. E.g. Petrus
Hispanus (the only medical doctor who
became the Pope till today!),
Paracelsus.
Cf. Paul Chummar Chittilappilly:
Zwischen Kosmos und Zeit. Zum Gespräch
zwischen Medizin und Ethik. Frankfurter
Beiträge zur Geschichte, Theorie und
Ethik der Medizin. Bd. 14. –
(Hildesheim, Zürich, New York:
Olms-Weidmann) 2000, p. 192-195;
199-201.
[14]
G. Cottier: “Is AIDS a Sign of Times?”
In: To live: Why? AIDS. – Proceedings of
the Fourth International Conference.
Dolentium Hominum No 13, 1990, p.38.
[15]
The writings of Hildegard of Bingen
about the Nature, Universe, Persons in
the Nature, the Constitution of Body
etc. are great sources of
anthropological understanding.
[16]
Hildegard von Bingen: Liber Divinorum
Operum VI, 5, cit. in: H. Schipperges:
Hildegard von Bingen. – (München: C. H.
Beck) 21995, p. 56.
[17]
L. Magesa: “AIDS and Survival in Africa:
a tentative reflection.” In: J. N. K.
Mugambi/A. Nasike (Ed.): Moral and
Ethical Issues in African Christianity.
A Challenge for African Christianity.
-
(Nairobi. Action Publishers) 32003.
p. 197.
[18]
J. S. Mbiti: African religions and
philosophy.
-
(Nairobi: East African Educational
Publishers) 182002, p.
147-148.
[19]
J. S. Mbiti: African religions and
philosophy. p. 141.
[20]
J. S. Mbiti: African religions and
philosophy. p. 148.
[21]
Even psychologically this separation of
the umbilical cord from the parents
family and house has to happen for the
stability and growth of the newly
erected family of wedded.
[22]
L. Magesa: “AIDS and Survival in Africa:
a tentative reflection.”, p. 198.
[23]
AIDS is believed by some people as the
punishment of dishonesty and cheating in
a business trade. Cf. E. Hooper: Slim: A
Reporter’s Own Story of AIDS in East
Africa.-
(London) 1990, p. 59.
[24]
L. Magesa: “AIDS and Survival in Africa:
a tentative reflection.”, p. 199.
[25]
L. Magesa: “AIDS and Survival in Africa:
a tentative reflection.”, p. 200.
[26]
Cf. Claude Wiéner. „Ehe“. In: Wörterbuch
zur Biblischen Botschaft. Xavier
Léon-Dufour (Ed.).
-
Freiburg i. Br. (Herder) 21967,
p. 114.
[27]
Cf. Translation of M. Gatterer:
Catechismus Romanus. Das Relgionsbuch
der Kirche (veröffentlicht in 1566).
-
Innsbruck 1934, No. 14, 15, 27.
[28]
The present Pope John Paul II emphasises
and supports the dignity of married life
and even equates in its status with a
celibate life of priests and religious
people.
|